If you search for an Arizona agency that polices homeowners associations, the Department of Real Estate is what comes up, and its own page is blunt about the limits. The department does not investigate associations, it does not discipline boards or managers, and it will not tell you what your association is allowed to do. What it does run is a hearing process under A.R.S. title 32, chapter 20, article 11. An owner or the association can petition for a hearing about violations of the community documents or of the statutes that regulate planned communities and condominiums. The petition is written, on the department's form, and it comes with a filing fee set by the commissioner. The statute does not print the dollar amount of that fee. The department mails the petition by certified mail, and the other side has twenty days to respond. If the parties settle before a hearing is scheduled, the fee can be refunded. The department's page says the fee is not refunded once the Office of Administrative Hearings has set a date. A petition filed by or against a renter, a non-owner, an individual director, or a management company will not be processed. The statute also keeps the department out of fights between owners when the association is not a party, and out of design, construction, and sale disputes with the developer.
The day-to-day rules for a planned community sit in title 33, chapter 16. Start with the books, because most arguments stall until someone can see them.
Looking at the books
Section 33-1805 says financial and other records must be made reasonably available to a member, or to a person the member names in writing. The association cannot charge you for making the material available to review. It has ten business days to fulfill a request for examination. If you ask to purchase copies, it has ten business days to provide them, and the copy fee cannot be more than fifteen cents a page. The association can withhold the part of a record that is a privileged communication with its lawyer, that concerns pending litigation, that is minutes of a session the open-meeting law did not require to be open, or that is personal, health, or financial information about a member or an employee. It also does not have to disclose a record if disclosure would violate another state or federal law.
Penalties, and the letter you can send back
Section 33-1803 lets the board impose reasonable monetary penalties for violations of the declaration, bylaws, and rules, but only after notice and an opportunity to be heard. That subsection does not set a dollar ceiling on the penalty. It does cap the late charge on an unpaid penalty: not more than the greater of fifteen dollars or ten percent of the unpaid penalty. A payment is not late until it is unpaid fifteen days after the due date, unless the documents give a longer period. Money paid on an unpaid penalty is applied to the principal first, then to interest. The notice has to explain how the penalty will be enforced.
The same section covers a written notice that the condition of your property violates the community documents, whether or not the notice also imposes a penalty. You can answer by certified mail within twenty-one calendar days, sent to the address on the notice. Within ten business days after that certified letter arrives, the association has to write back with the provision you allegedly broke, the date of the violation or the date it was observed, the first and last name of the person who observed it, and the process for contesting the notice, unless the original notice already included those items. If the contest process was not in the original notice, the association is not supposed to go forward with enforcement, including collection of attorney fees, before that exchange is done. The statute also tells the association to give you written notice of the option to petition the real estate department, if the dispute is one that office can hear.
A separate limit in the same section is about regular assessments, not fines. Unless the documents set a lower cap, the association cannot impose a regular assessment more than twenty percent above the prior fiscal year's assessment without approval of a majority of the members. A late charge on an unpaid assessment is also limited to the greater of fifteen dollars or ten percent, and only after notice that the assessment is overdue.
Meetings, and voting without a proxy
Section 33-1804 opens meetings of the members, the board, and regularly scheduled committees to members and to a representative a member names in writing. You are allowed to speak once after the board discusses a specific agenda item and before it votes on that item, on top of any other speaking time. The board can put reasonable time limits on speakers. A meeting of the members has to be held at least once a year, and meetings of the members and the board have to be held in Arizona. The president, a majority of the board, or members holding at least twenty-five percent of the votes (or any lower percentage the bylaws set) can call a special meeting of the members. Notice goes out not fewer than ten and not more than fifty days ahead, by hand delivery or prepaid United States mail, and it has to state the purpose, including the general nature of a proposed amendment, an assessment change that needs member approval, or a proposal to remove a director or officer. After declarant control ends, board meetings need at least forty-eight hours' notice, except when emergency circumstances require action before notice can be given.
Once the period of declarant control ends, section 33-1812 bans proxies, whatever the community documents say. The association has to provide for votes in person and by absentee ballot, and it may also allow email, fax, or another form of delivery. If absentee ballots are used, each ballot has to set out the proposed actions, give a way to vote for or against each one, and expire when that election or meeting is over. The deadline printed on the ballot has to be at least seven days after the board delivers the blank ballot to the member. The completed ballot carries the voter's name, address, and signature, unless the documents allow a secret ballot, in which case that information goes on the envelope. Ballots, envelopes, and sign-in sheets are kept for at least a year and made available for member inspection. Votes cast by absentee ballot or other delivery count for a quorum.
The meetings section does not set a percentage that constitutes a quorum at an ordinary annual meeting. It does set one for a special meeting to remove a director who was not appointed by the declarant. Under section 33-1813, a quorum at that meeting is owners eligible to vote equal to at least twenty percent of the votes, or one thousand votes, whichever is less. In an association of one thousand or fewer members, a petition signed by the lesser of twenty-five percent of the votes or one hundred votes requires the board to call the meeting. In a larger association the petition threshold is the lesser of ten percent or one thousand votes. The meeting has to be called, noticed, and held within thirty days after the petition arrives. Removal is by a majority of those voting on the question, with or without cause. If the board fails to hold the meeting, the directors are deemed removed at midnight of the thirty-first day. A petition to remove the same director cannot be submitted more than once during that director's term.